Skip to main content
healthy for your kids
and healthy for you

Create the perfect yogurt ice cream at home

Master the craft of homemade yogurt ice cream with our guide.

Learn which yogurt to choose for a creamy result, how to refine the texture, and how to infuse delightful flavors. No ice cream machine? No problem. We’ll show you how it’s done.

Freezing yogurts

  • High-fat content is crucial for a creamy texture in homemade frozen yogurt, but balance is key to avoid greasiness or a too watery result.
  • You can make creamy frozen yogurt without an ice cream machine by using alternate methods like freezing and stirring or using a food processor.
  • Get creative with mix-ins and toppings like fruity flavors, chocolate chips, or even homemade sauces to customize the flavor of your frozen yogurt.

Discovering the best yogurt for your ice cream

Creating the perfect homemade frozen yogurt begins with choosing the right base. The type of yogurt you pick can make the difference between an icy, granular texture and a creamy, luscious treat. The secret lies in the consistency and fat content of your chosen yogurt.

Greek yogurt, known for its thick consistency, makes an ideal base for your frozen delight. Thanks to its thickness, it helps to alleviate the icy texture often caused by the water content in yogurt when frozen. Meanwhile, whole-milk yogurt, with its high fat content, aids in achieving a creamier texture, preventing an icy consistency. Low fat greek yogurt can also be a healthier alternative, while still maintaining a satisfyingly creamy texture, even without the thickeners or high sugar levels found in commercial brands.

The role of fat content

Let’s face it, we all love the rich, creamy texture of our favorite frozen yogurt brands. But did you know that the secret to that creaminess is all about the fat content? Indeed, the higher fat content in yogurt is key to achieving that rich, creamy texture in your homemade frozen yogurt. Regular frozen yogurt typically contains 3-6% butterfat, which is integral to the product’s creaminess and structural firmness.

But it’s not just about pumping in as much fat as you can. There’s a balancing act at play here. An excessive fat content can cause the frozen yogurt to become greasy and overly hard, while too little fat can create a watery and coarse texture. And did you know that the fat content also modulates flavor release? Higher fat leads to a subdued, lingering taste, while lower fat offers an immediate, brighter flavor profile. So next time you’re whipping up a batch of homemade frozen yogurt, remember, it’s all about balance!

Flavor foundations

But the journey to the perfect homemade frozen yogurt doesn’t just stop at fat content. There’s a whole world of flavor foundations to explore! The type of yogurt you choose - be it vanilla, strained, or non-dairy - can significantly impact the final flavor, texture, and appearance of your frozen yogurt.

Strained yogurt, for instance, lowers the pH of the frozen dessert mixture more significantly than set yogurt, affecting its taste and texture. To produce a denser and creamier strained yogurt, you can strain plain whole-milk yogurt with cheesecloth in the refrigerator for at least 6 hours before using it in your recipe. But what about Greek yogurt, you ask? While it can lead to a less desirable texture in frozen yogurt recipes, straining plain whole-milk yogurt at home is preferable for achieving creaminess without chalkiness.

So, ready to lay down the flavor foundations for your frozen treat?

Crafting creamier frozen yogurt

Now that we’ve got our plain yogurt base sorted, let’s move on to crafting that dreamy, creamy texture. And no, we’re not talking about a high-powered ice cream machine or complicated techniques. Even the simplest of ingredients, like strained yogurt or corn syrup, can be your secret weapons here.

Strained yogurt contributes to the enhanced texture and nutritional profile of frozen desserts. But remember, balance is key. The optimum content of strained yogurt in your frozen dessert should be around 10%. This helps to balance sensory and textural properties without increasing the hardness and chewiness of your frozen yogurt. And here’s a bonus tip: try incorporating ingredients like sliced frozen banana or unflavored gelatin. These can help prevent the formation of large ice crystals, contributing to the creaminess of your frozen yogurt.

Embracing heavy cream

So, we’ve got our yogurt base and our strained yogurt ready. What’s next? It’s time to embrace the magic of heavy cream! Adding heavy cream to your frozen yogurt can enrich the yogurt mixture, resulting in a creamier texture similar to that of traditional ice cream.

Heavy cream contributes to a smoother frozen yogurt texture by increasing the fat content. This enables better interaction with air and other ingredients, resulting in a richer and creamier consistency. Plus, the increased fat content from heavy cream coats the tongue, reducing the perception of cold and thereby enhancing the creamy sensation of the frozen yogurt.

So, ready to embrace the power of heavy cream in your homemade frozen yogurt?

Sweetening strategies

We’ve talked about the fat, the cream, and the texture. Now, let’s sweeten the deal! Sugar is more than just a sweetener in your frozen yogurt. It also helps maintain the sweetness while decreasing the formation of ice crystals, leading to a creamier texture.

But sugar is not the only sweetening agent in town. Corn syrup, maple syrup, and even Lyle’s Golden Syrup can serve as effective sweeteners. They not only enhance the frozen yogurt’s texture by preventing large ice crystals but also lower the freezing point for improved scooping.

Liquid sweeteners like honey or agave nectar can add a glossy appearance and desirable mouthfeel to your frozen yogurt. To create a flavorful homemade frozen yogurt, try a blend of honey and granulated sugar, and enhance the taste with vanilla extract. Now, that’s a sweet deal!

The homemade yogurt ice cream process

So far, we’ve been gathering our ingredients and discussing the key elements that make a perfect homemade frozen yogurt. Now, it’s time to get to the heart of the matter - the actual process of making our frozen treat! This process involves combining all your ingredients, which may include yogurt, sweeteners, flavorings, and optionally ¼ cup of heavy whipping cream to enhance creaminess, in a large mixing bowl.

Next, to make frozen yogurt, follow these steps:

  1. Mix all the ingredients together in a bowl until well combined.
  2. Pour the mixed ingredients into an ice cream maker and churn according to the manufacturer’s instructions, usually for 35-40 minutes, or until a creamy texture and consistency are achieved.
  3. After churning to a soft serve consistency, transfer the frozen yogurt to a container with a lid.
  4. Freeze the container for at least 2 hours to obtain a firmer texture suitable for scooping.

Enjoy the best frozen yogurt with frozen fruit - your homemade frozen yogurt!

But what if you don’t have a Cuisinart ice cream maker or any other ice cream maker? Don’t worry, we’ve got you covered!

Churning to perfection

One of the most crucial steps in making your homemade frozen yogurt is churning. Churning is what gives your frozen treat that smooth, creamy texture we all know and love. To achieve this, simply pour the yogurt base into your ice cream machine and churn until thick, which can take anywhere from 17 to 20 minutes for a firmer consistency, or 35 to 40 minutes for a consistency that resembles soft serve ice cream.

But remember, patience is key. It’s crucial to adhere to the specific churning instructions provided by the manufacturer of the ice cream maker for the best results. Even though it might be tempting to cut the churning process short, remaining patient during this step is essential to ensure the yogurt mixture reaches the correct creamy texture. After all, good things come to those who wait, right?

Without an ice cream machine

So, you don’t have an ice cream maker? Don’t let that stop you from making your own delicious frozen yogurt! Even without an ice cream machine, there are several methods you can use to whip up your own batch of this creamy treat.

One option is the freeze and stir technique, which involves combining your ingredients in a bowl, freezing the mixture, and stirring occasionally to prevent the formation of ice crystals.

Alternatively, you can use a food processor to blend your ingredients into a smooth, milkshake-like mixture. After preparing the frozen yogurt mixture in a food processor, transfer it to a freezer-safe container, cover it tightly, and freeze until it is firm.

Who said you need an expensive machine to enjoy homemade frozen yogurt?

Flavor infusions and mix-ins

We’ve got our base, we’ve got our cream, and we’ve got our sweetener. What’s next? It’s time to get creative with flavor infusions and mix-ins! Adding different flavors such as mango, raspberry, or even chocolate to your basic frozen yogurt recipe can create a variety of delicious options.

Whether you’re a fruit lover or a chocolate devotee, there’s a flavor for everyone. Some popular flavor combinations include:

  • Fresh berries with a hint of lemon
  • Chocolate and peanut butter
  • Vanilla and caramel
  • Mint and chocolate
  • Strawberry and banana

But remember, the key is to experiment and find your own personal favorite combinations. After all, who knows your taste buds better than you?

Fruitful delights

If you’re a fan of fruity flavors, this is your chance to shine. Adding fruit mix-ins like berries or mango can add a natural sweetness and a boost of vitamin C to your frozen yogurt. To do this, simply combine 1 cup of mixed frozen fruits with 1/2 cup of vanilla Greek yogurt in a blender.

But why stop at berries and mango? From fresh blueberries and raspberries to sliced kiwi, the options are endless. And if you want to add a refreshing twist, try sprinkling some fresh mint leaves over your frozen yogurt for a cool, refreshing flavor that perfectly complements the fruit toppings.

Indulgent additions

If you’re looking for something a little more indulgent, why not add some chocolate chips or edible cookie dough to your yogurt ice cream? These rich flavors and textures can significantly elevate your homemade dessert experience.

Whether you’re a fan of a simple homemade chocolate sauce or prefer the tangy sweetness of a homemade strawberry sauce, there’s an indulgent addition for every palate. And for a smooth, rich contrast that enhances the sweet and tangy flavors of your yogurt ice cream, why not try a drizzle of salted caramel sauce?. It’s time to give your frozen treat the indulgent upgrade it deserves!

Storing and serving your frozen creation

Now that we’ve crafted our delicious homemade frozen yogurt, it’s time to store and serve our frozen creation. Proper storage is vital to maintain the texture and prevent freezer burn. For optimal storage, use plastic tubs, glass jars, or silicone containers with tight-fitting lids.

When you’re ready to serve, remember to:

  • Let your frozen yogurt soften at room temperature for a few minutes
  • Use long, shallow strokes with an ice cream scoop for perfect scoops
  • Remember that presentation is key when you’re serving up your homemade masterpiece!

Airtight solutions

The key to maintaining the quality and creaminess of your homemade frozen yogurt lies in how you store it. Airtight storage solutions, such as plastic tubs or glass jars, can help preserve your frozen yogurt for up to a month without losing its creamy consistency due to ice crystal formation.

But it’s not just about popping your tub into the freezer. Placing a piece of parchment paper directly on the surface of the frozen yogurt mixture before sealing helps prevent ice crystals and maintain creaminess. And for those plastic tubs, make sure the lid is snapped on securely and pressed down on all edges for an airtight seal.

Remember, a little extra effort in storage can go a long way in preserving the quality of your homemade treat!

Ready to enjoy

After all the hard work and patience, it’s finally time to enjoy your homemade frozen yogurt! But before you dig in, let’s talk about thawing. For a slow thawing process, transfer the frozen yogurt from the freezer to the refrigerator and allow it to thaw gradually, either overnight or for a few hours prior to serving.

If you need a quicker thawing method, leave the sealed container of frozen yogurt at room temperature for about 20-30 minutes. But be cautious to avoid letting it melt excessively. Once the frozen yogurt is adequately thawed to the desired consistency, let it sit on the counter for 20 to 30 minutes until it’s soft enough to scoop, then serve.

Or if you’re in a hurry, why not enjoy it in glasses as a milkshake or smoothie without waiting for it to harden? After all, the best part about homemade frozen yogurt is that you get to enjoy it exactly the way you like it!

Pairing with toppings and sauces

We’ve got our creamy homemade frozen yogurt ready. Now, let’s dress it up! The beauty of homemade frozen yogurt is that you can pair it with a variety of toppings and sauces, inviting both freshness and decadence into each serving.

From topping your yogurt ice cream with fresh fruits to layering it with granola and honey for a parfait, the possibilities are endless. And the best part? You can experiment with different serving suggestions to discover your personal favorite ways to enjoy your homemade yogurt ice cream. So, ready to deck out your frozen treat?

The freshness factor

What’s better than a scoop of creamy frozen yogurt? A scoop of creamy frozen yogurt topped with fresh fruits! Adding fresh fruits to your yogurt ice cream introduces a natural and refreshing twist to the dessert.

Whether you prefer the tangy burst of fresh blueberries, the sweet tartness of raspberries, or the tropical flavor of sliced kiwi, fresh fruit toppings can add a whole new dimension to your frozen yogurt. And for an added refreshing twist, sprinkle some fresh mint leaves over your frozen yogurt for a cool, invigorating flavor that perfectly complements the sweetness of the fruit toppings. Ready to add a freshness factor to your frozen treat?

Decadent drizzles

If you’re more inclined towards the indulgent side of desserts, why not elevate your frozen yogurt with some decadent drizzles? Here are some homemade sauces that add a personal touch and can be tailored to the desired sweetness and intensity of flavors for your yogurt ice cream:

  • Chocolate sauce
  • Caramel sauce
  • Strawberry sauce
  • Peanut butter sauce
  • Raspberry sauce

From a rich homemade chocolate sauce to a fresh and tangy homemade strawberry sauce, there’s a drizzle for every palate. And for a smooth, rich contrast that enhances the sweet and tangy flavors of your yogurt ice cream, try a drizzle of salted caramel sauce. Ready to drizzle your way to a decadent dessert?

Creamier frozen yogurt

We’ve taken you on a journey from selecting the perfect yogurt base to crafting a creamy texture, adding delicious flavor infusions, and perfecting the art of storage and serving. We’ve explored the magic of heavy cream, the sweetness of various sweeteners, and the fun of creative mix-ins. And we’ve done it all without the need for a fancy ice cream machine!

Now, it’s over to you. Armed with these tips and tricks, you’re all set to create your own perfect yogurt ice cream at home. So, gather your ingredients, fire up that imagination, and make every scoop your masterpiece. After all, the magic of homemade frozen yogurt is that it’s a reflection of you, your creativity, and your taste buds. Ready to create your creamy dream?

Is yogurt ice cream healthy?

While frozen yogurt contains less fat and calories than ice cream, it can still have high sugar content, so it should be enjoyed in moderation as a healthier dessert option.

Can I freeze yogurt like ice cream?

Yes, you can freeze yogurt to enjoy it like ice cream. The texture might be a bit firmer, but it's still a great healthy snack option.

What is yogurt ice cream made of?

Yogurt ice cream is made of milk, yogurt cultures, and sugar, with additional flavors like cocoa, vanilla, fruits, and sweeteners added for taste. Enjoy!

What is the difference between yogurt ice cream and regular ice cream?

The main difference between yogurt ice cream and regular ice cream lies in their ingredients. While ice cream is made from milk and/or cream, frozen yogurt is made from yogurt, resulting in a tangier taste due to the lactic acid in yogurt. Additionally, regular ice cream typically contains more total fat than frozen yogurt, with ice cream requiring at least 10% milk fat compared to the 2-6% milk fat in frozen yogurt.

Is mixing yogurt and ice cream good?

Mixing yogurt and ice cream can be a great idea, as it creates a tasty and tangy treat with a unique flavor. Give it a try and adjust the yogurt to your preference!